Power was off from large storm . Whole town was out. Nothing the Inn could do about that.. not a complaint. We just didn’t get to fully enjoy the fire pits and balcony due to the weather. That is a positive amenity others will enjoy.

Shelley was awesome. Friendly, helpful and the breakfast was amazing .

Stayed in June 2024

Property was quiet

The Main house was gorgeous and it where we had breakfast which was perfect. Our room was in the Dempsey house and although the main floor/parlor was simple our room upstairs was wonderful, complete with a balcony. Weather was dreary, wet and cold so we didn’t take advantage of balcony. Shelly, the Inn keeper was wonderful and explained everything to us and made our breakfast. The place was immaculate. We know we will choose the BennConger Inn on our next trip upstate again.

Stayed in June 2024

Awesome place to stay and the inn keeper genuinely cares for her guests. Highly recommend!

Stayed in June 2024

The only unconvinced thing that happened to us was power outages because of a storm. So most of the night we didn’t had electricity and it was very hot, the windows can’t be open so we suffered from the heat. But otherwise everything was very very good.

Very special antique house with all kind of antique features: the furniture, art, dining plats and silverware…. The house kippers were very very nice, welcoming, taking care of us, very very tasty and rich breakfast. Nice big green yard and gardens.

Stayed in June 2024

We enjoyed a lovely one night stay at this beautifully restored historic inn. Our suite was large, comfortable, and tastefully decorated. Shelly was a delight to talk to, and provided very personalized service. The cook to order breakfast was very good, especially Shelly’s homemade cinnamon rolls. It was very interesting to learn the history of the family connection to the inn, and what a family project it is. We would definitely recommend a stay at the Benn Conger Inn, and hope to return on a future trip!

Stayed in June 2024

Nothing Would always stay here when in the area.

Shelly was a great host.Let us know about the area and the wonderful history of the Inn.Breakfast was above and beyond what we expected.

Stayed in June 2024

Nothing.

The inn was set back off the road with a lovely well tended lawn and it looked so majestic and inviting. Our room, the Terrance Graves was in the Dempsey House next door. We were on the second floor, although a wee bit small, met all our needs and the balcony was a bonus. Our antique brass bed that had a step stool and was oh so comfortable. Breakfast was prepared by Shelley and all the pastries and scones were baked by her. We had a veggie omelettes which were the best we had ever eaten. You have a choice of three dining areas with a view of nature from the main house. Shelley, who also serves as the Innkeeper made our stay comfortable and delightful! Thank you🌷

Stayed in June 2024

Very clean and well appointed Inn. We stayed in Dempsey House next door to Inn. Newly renovated and super clean. Wonderful Innkeeper. Excellent breakfast.

Stayed in May 2024

My only comment would be that we used the bathtub and lots of brown stuff (dirt/dust) came out of the jets and we didn't notice it until after the bath (due to the bubbles) so that was kind of gross...I guess because they aren't used much?

Our host was amazing - the food was delicious!

Stayed in May 2024

Nothing

What a delightful place. Lovely hosts and great old fashion service. Breakfast was great and the area was lovely and peaceful. My wife wanted to stay another night, but it was booked out. Loved it.

Stayed in May 2024

Just wish we could have reserved the first floor since I use a cane.

Location and loved the decor.

Stayed in May 2024

That I couldn't stay longer!

We enjoyed our mother, daughter, and granddaughter's weekend so much! Our stay at the Ben Conger Inn, was the icing on the cake for a relaxing weekend of shopping. The GM, Drew, emailed prior to, and reached out by phone out on our check in date to see if we had any request or what they could do to make our stay better. That was above and beyond anything I expected. Mrs. Shelley, the Inn keeper was such a pleasant host. She made sure we had all the information we needed for a perfect stay. The morning breakfast was spot on. You start with a lovely presentation of Continental breakfast only to be served a made to order.hot breakfast. Again, above and beyond. I highly recommend this lovely Inn!

Stayed in May 2024

The inn was beautiful! We were greeted warmly and the host made sure we had everything we needed. The breakfast was delicious and the room that we stayed in was extremely comfortable! I would highly recommend this hotel.

Stayed in April 2024

Beautiful property with a very interesting history which we enjoyed listening to over a lovely breakfast with our host. We were attending acceptance day at Ithaca College and so glad we chose to stay here. Extremely clean, comfortable, spacious and easy to find.

Stayed in April 2024

Nothing

Amazing beautiful house and very friendly owners!

Stayed in April 2024

Everything was great

The accommodations were excellent. Very peaceful, home away from home. Beautiful stately main home, exquisitely decorated. Served full delicious breakfast, made to order, poached eggs to perfection. Staff went above and beyond to explain the history of the Benn Conger Inn and makes us feel very welcomed.

Stayed in April 2024

Shelly the hostess was phenomenal.

Stayed in April 2024

Unable to open windows

Loved the historic charm of the building, Friendly staff, welcomed us like we were home

Stayed in April 2024

Beautiful property that exceeded our expectations. Everything was very comfortable, the staff was amazing.

Stayed in April 2024

Shelley, the innkeeper, was outstanding in service, help, and knowledge about the history of the Inn and the surrounding area. Great stay. Looking forward to our next one.

Stayed in April 2024

Everything was perfect. It was very convenient to get to Ithaca

Everything!! Shelly and Drew were wonderful host. The inn is beautiful and the breakfast is amazing! Shelly really made us feel at home. Every morning she had the breakfast sun room filled with delicious coffee, juices, teas and hot chocolate. She had wonderful bread, muffins, fresh fruit and more. Then she prepared a cooked meal of our choice. We had pancakes, French toast and omelettes. Our room was perfect. Drew upgraded us to a larger room. It was lovely overlooking the back lawn. It had a beautiful gas fireplace and Shelly had coffee and tea available as well.

Stayed in March 2024

Historic and beautiful option outside Ithaca. Would definitely stay here again given the surroundings but specially the charm of the room and the house itself. That breakfast (OMG the homemade pumpkin pancakes) with those garden views remain as one of the highlights of our trip. In additon, we booked last minute and they were super helpful and arrival was easy and smooth.

Stayed in November 2023

Nothing

Really beautiful house with amazing people

Stayed in December 2023

The whole house looks great, like turning back the clock. The breakfast was awesome, and our Innkeeper Shirley was really amazing, she helped us a lot, we were travelling with a baby

Stayed in November 2023