The view from our room was a car repair shop. But that wasn't a big deal for us. We closed the curtains. We wanted a hotel that was close to the West entrance of Yellowstone National Park. So the view from our room wasn't important.

Breakfast selection was great. I love the rustic design. The entire hotel smells like the spas I've been to in Bali, Indonesia. Our room was very clean. I love the bathroom with its towel warmer. The location of the hotel is so close to the Yellowstone National Park West entrance.

Stayed in September 2024

No elevator for luggage however only have to go up 1 flight of stairs and the staff were happy to help.

It was modern yet authentic and cosy. Friendly staff and fantastic continental breakfast. Easy to access main attractions in the park

Stayed in September 2024

The room was a little bit small, and the pricing was a bit too much for the hotel offering.

The staff was very firendly, the breakfast was good and the room was clean. The sauna is a great feature to use after a long day of hiking.

Stayed in July 2024

Nothing. It’s relatively expensive but worth it.

A gorgeous little haven of a hotel, very near the west entrance of Yellowstone. Breakfast is simple, typical American but the quality of the food they give you is top notch. Rooms are beautifully decorated, very comfy beds and fantastic bathroom (biggest shower I’ve ever seen!)

Stayed in September 2024

The food could be fresher. Fruit wasn’t very fresh, muffins were hard and oatmeal was watery.

Beautiful hotel. Every detail was amazing.

Stayed in September 2024

Room.was pretty.small for the price Housekeeping was iffy, only changed sheets once during 3 night stay For what we paid I expected every day They left empty window cleaner in the bathroom

Stayed in September 2024

We were there on the weekend and breakfast baked goods were stale and inedible. No elevator.

Rooms are very nice and clean.

Stayed in September 2024

Exceptional

Stayed in July 2024

Like it all. The room was small for the price

Gas fireplace in room

Stayed in August 2024

Overpriced

Location Room was nice Breakfast was substantial. More than continental.

Stayed in August 2024

Love our stay at 1872. If I go to West Yellowstone ever again that's where my husband and I will be staying. Everything was top notch!!

Stayed in August 2024

The location.... The Staff..... The room

Stayed in August 2024

Loved the staff. Room was great.

Stayed in August 2024

Great nicer hotel in West Yellowstone.

Stayed in May 2024

No good views

Definitely five stars all around Out of this world breakfast buffet! Excellent shower and amenities

Stayed in June 2024

Air conditioning a bit noisy. Pillows too soft. Not enough space in wardrobe.

Brand new, bathroom with toiletries double shower and heater for the towels, coffee machine and beverages free in the room fridge, different and various fruits at breakfast, very good yogurt, fresh orange juice and good scrambled eggs with vegetables.

Stayed in July 2024

The breakfast was wonderful! Many choices...fresh...healthy...high quality. We were happy with the choices and enjoyed the breakfast.

Stayed in June 2024

Beautiful facility great staff

Stayed in July 2024

The room was nice and comfortable but felt a little cramped and lacked nightstands by the bed. The fridge was pretty small but that really was not an issue for our stay. The bathroom was a good size with a nice shower.

The hotel offered basic amenities and comforts, is in a good location, it was clean, comfortable, and definitely a great value when compared to many of the other hotels in the area. Driving a few extra minutes to save hundreds of dollars is a no brainer in my opinion.

Stayed in June 2024

Hotel is spotless and very comfortable. Room with fireplace was nice on cold night. Bathroom was amazing. Free breakfast was super!!

Stayed in June 2024

This place was amazing! There’s nothing I didn’t like.

Everything about this place was amazing! The rooms were very clean and cozy. The staff was wonderful-I loved the fact that you get a tour of your room and all the amenities. The breakfast was delicious. It was so quiet and relaxing. It was only a mile from the west entrance of Yellowstone. I can’t say enough great things about this place. I will definitely recommend this place to everyone!

Stayed in May 2024

The only negative. which they state, is there is no elevator. If you are on the second floor, just be prepared to take stairs with your luggage. It was not a big deal.

The 1872 INN was perfect! Great location, super clean, excellent breakfast and the cozy Montana feel you are wanting! The Sauna was a nice perk! The beds were very comfortable and the in-room fireplace provided the perfect romantic setting. I am certain it is one of the nicest places to stay in West Yellowstone. I could not recommend this property enough.

Stayed in June 2024

Very comfortable and furnished to high standard, helpful staff. 2 minutes drive to park entrance

Stayed in June 2024

Nothing

Such a cool vibe in this boutique property. They have paid attention to detail for sure. The fireplace, double sinks with his and hers products, robes and fridge with complimentary drinks are nice touches. The bed was seriously the most comfortable one I have EVER slept in…mattress, sheets and pillows are all top notch. We loved sitting in the cozy lobby playing games after a fun day in Yellowstone. The breakfast in the morning was yummy. And the staff was over the top helpful and kind. I would stay here again in a heartbeat!

Stayed in June 2024