Skip to main content

Inns in Put-in-Bay

Find the inns that appeal to you the most

—

May 2024

12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031

June 2024

12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
Check-in date - Check-out date

The 10 Best Inns in Put-in-Bay, USA

Check out our pick of great inns in Put-in-Bay

Filter by:

Review score

Superb: 9+ Very good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Our top picks Lowest price first Star rating and price Top reviewed

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

Ahoy Inn Guesthouse, inn in Put-in-Bay

Ahoy Inn Guesthouse is set in Put-in-Bay, 24 km from Sandusky and 48 km from Leamington. The property offers European styled rooms, free WiFi and private parking.

Every room includes a flat-screen TV with cable channels, a refrigerator and air conditioning. Some rooms feature a balcony or a terrace. Other amenities include a coffee maker, nightstands with reading lamps and alarm clocks.

The room and the bathroom was very nice and clean. Nick was very helpful for recommending dining options. The inn was very close to downtown and various eating/drinking establishments. I would stay there again.

Show more Show less
9.1
Superb
238 reviews
Price from
£122
per night
Check availability
Bodee's Bungalow Adults Only Couples Only Boutique Hotel, inn in Put-in-Bay

Set in Put-in-Bay, Bodee's Bungalow Adults Only Couples Only Boutique Hotel provides most accommodations with private entrances. With barbecue facilities, the property also has a garden. Complimentary WiFi is provided for all guests.

The place was super clean and in great repair. Staff was great to work with. The bed was wonderful and that is rare from my perspective. Shower and water pressure were excellent as well.

Show more Show less
9.6
Exceptional
34 reviews
Price from
£121
per night
Check availability
All inns in Put-in-Bay

Looking for an inn?

Perfect for rustic breaks in the countryside, an Inn is a small property with basic hotel services and typically traditional decor. Inns are fully licensed and have a bar providing food and drinks in the evening, which distinguishes them from country or guest houses.
Search inns in Put-in-Bay

Inns that guests love in Put-in-Bay

  • Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

    Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

    Inn in Put-in-Bay
    Avg. price/night: £266.82
    9.5
    Scored 9.5
    Exceptional
    Rated exceptional
     · 171 reviews
    We reserved the only main floor room for easy access to our car. It was ready early and we dropped off our luggage early. The innkeepers provide a made-to-order breakfast every day. Choices of inside & outdoor dining. Spacious room was well appointed and maintained. Easy (1/4 mi) walking distance downtown and winery. Good security. Adult oriented.
    B
    Brian
    Young couple
  • Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

    Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

    Inn in Put-in-Bay
    Avg. price/night: £131.15
    9.1
    Scored 9.1
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 237 reviews
    The location is perfect and the inn keeper is very nice. The bathroom was clean. The inn felt safe and was quiet.
    Kylee
    Young couple
  • Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

    Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

    Inn in Put-in-Bay
    Avg. price/night: £266.82
    9.5
    Scored 9.5
    Exceptional
    Rated exceptional
     · 171 reviews
    Both the Inn and the staff are lovely and we hope to be able to come back in the future! There were lots of personal touches while everything was also done in a highly professional manner (e.g. the turndown service), which made our stay so special! It was quiet at night, too, which was an especially nice contrast to the noisy parties downtown (right around the corner).
    Julia
    Young couple
  • Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

    Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

    Inn in Put-in-Bay
    Avg. price/night: £131.15
    9.1
    Scored 9.1
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 237 reviews
    The room and the bathroom was very nice and clean. Nick was very helpful for recommending dining options. The inn was very close to downtown and various eating/drinking establishments. I would stay there again.
    Barbara
    Young couple
  • Islander Inn

    Islander Inn

    Inn in Put-in-Bay
    Avg. price/night: £159.10
    7.4
    Scored 7.4
    Good
    Rated good
     · 270 reviews
    The staff was amazing and helpful. The security team was attentive and friendly. The location was amazing, with a very short walk to the main area on the island. I loved being able to rent a cart from the Inn rather than hoping to get one from the vendor. The front desk staff was amazing and helpful. I even used the text service for a cab number when i was stuck further away and received an answer within a timely major, which was a life saver.
    Guajardo
    Young couple
  • Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

    Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

    Inn in Put-in-Bay
    Avg. price/night: £131.15
    9.1
    Scored 9.1
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 237 reviews
    Cleanest hotel and grounds ever! My sister and I came to the island for a two night, three day stay. Ahoy Inn was everything we needed. We enjoyed the peaceful, quiet neighborhood that was close to shops and restaurants. We used the Inn’s bicycles to take a look around. This Inn is simple charm, no extravagance, just everything you need in a charming setting. We highly recommend it!
    Elaine
    Family with young children
  • Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

    Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

    Inn in Put-in-Bay
    Avg. price/night: £131.15
    9.1
    Scored 9.1
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 237 reviews
    I liked how quiet the Ahoy Inn Guest house was. The man who owned the property was very nice and informative, he didn't bother us at all which I loved the most. He'd only ask here and there if we needed something.
    Fracker
    Young couple
  • Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

    Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

    Inn in Put-in-Bay
    Avg. price/night: £131.15
    9.1
    Scored 9.1
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 237 reviews
    Ahoy Inn was very clean. It’s walking distance to everything but not in the middle of it so there was peace and quiet.
    April
    Young couple
  • Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

    Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

    Inn in Put-in-Bay
    Avg. price/night: £266.82
    9.5
    Scored 9.5
    Exceptional
    Rated exceptional
     · 171 reviews
    The Anchor Inn is a pleasant spot - very clean, well appointed too. Food was good and environment was calm and quiet. We plan to visit again!
    Michelle
    Young couple
  • Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

    Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

    Inn in Put-in-Bay
    Avg. price/night: £266.82
    9.5
    Scored 9.5
    Exceptional
    Rated exceptional
     · 171 reviews
    We were very happy with our experience at the Anchor Inn. It had lots of character and charm. Lovely place!
    M
    Marina
    Group
gogless