Skip to main content

The best cottages in Shelter Island Heights

Check out our selection of great cottages in Shelter Island Heights

Filter by:


Review Score

Wonderful: 9+ Very Good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Our top picks Lowest Price First Star rating and price Top reviewed

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

Boasting a spa bath, Shelter Island Retreat with Outdoor Pool! is set in Shelter Island. This beachfront property offers access to a balcony. Offering free WiFi throughout the property, the non-smoking holiday home has a fitness room.

Show more Show less
10
Exceptional
1 reviews

Boasting air-conditioned accommodation with a patio, Bright Oasis in Beautiful North Fork Wine Country is set in Southold. There is an outdoor fireplace and guests can make use of free WiFi and free private parking.

Show more Show less
10
Exceptional
1 reviews
Price from
£419
per night

Situated in Greenport, 42 km from Splish Splash, Greenport Home with Harbor View Near Ferry and Beaches features air-conditioned accommodation with a patio and free WiFi.

The spacious holiday home has 3 bedrooms, a TV and a fully equipped kitchen that provides guests with a dishwasher, an oven, a washing machine, a microwave and a fridge. Towels and bed linen are available in the holiday home. The property has an outdoor dining area.

Show more Show less

The spacious holiday home features 3 bedrooms, a TV, a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher and an oven, a washing machine, and 3 bathrooms with a walk-in shower. Towels and bed linen are provided in the holiday home. There is also a seating area and a fireplace.

Show more Show less
Price from
£296
per night

Featuring air-conditioned accommodation with a patio, Greenport village cottage w/ 4 bedrooms is set in Greenport. The property features garden views, and is 41 km from Splish Splash. There is a terrace and guests can make use of free WiFi, free private parking and an electric vehicle charging station.

Show more Show less
Price from
£744
per night

The spacious holiday home has 3 bedrooms, a TV, a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher and an oven, a washing machine, and 2 bathrooms with a bath. Towels and bed linen are offered in the holiday home. There is also a seating area and a fireplace.

Show more Show less
Price from
£318
per night

Featuring a sauna, Cozy Greenport Cottage is located in Greenport. This holiday home features a private pool and a garden. Free WiFi is available throughout the property and Splish Splash is 41 km away.

Show more Show less
Price from
£264
per night

The spacious holiday home has 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, bed linen, towels, a TV with cable channels, a dining area, a fully equipped kitchen, and a patio with garden views. Guests can take in the ambience of the surroundings from an outdoor dining area or keep themselves warm by the fireplace on colder days. For added privacy, the accommodation features a private entrance.

Show more Show less
Price from
£173
per night

The spacious holiday home comes with 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, bed linen, towels, a TV with satellite channels, a dining area, a fully equipped kitchen, and a balcony with sea views. There is also a seating area and a fireplace.

Show more Show less
Price from
£206
per night

Lagoon Lodge: North Fork, Charming 3Br, Waterfront is located in East Marion. The air-conditioned accommodation is 44 km from Splish Splash, and guests can benefit from on-site private parking and complimentary WiFi. Outdoor dining is also possible at the holiday home.

Show more Show less
Price from
£304
per night

Looking for a cottage?

Cottages are perfect for travelers who enjoy feeling cozy and independent in the countryside. Usually small, traditionally built houses, cottages are spread across one or two floors – making them great for families or vacations with a little more privacy.
Search cottages in Shelter Island Heights

Cottages That Guests Love in Shelter Island Heights

  • Avg. price/night: £248.09
    8.0
    Scored 8.0
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 26 reviews
    Stay here, you won't regret it! Beautiful old creaky house oozing charm and history, cosy dark wood abounds, a snug conservatory to play games in, a veranda with a swing, and out front chairs and a hammock on the waters edge. Great host, great house, great stay.
    Ralphoo
    Young couple
gogless