Skip to main content

Filter by:


Star rating

Review score

New Buffalo – 7 hotels and places to stay
See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
The Neighborhood Hotel Grand Beach, hotel in New Buffalo

Located in New Buffalo, The Neighborhood Hotel Grand Beach offers a terrace.

Fire pit was awesome, lovely room very peaceful short walk from a quiet beach
9.1
Scored 9.1
Superb
Rated superb
17 reviews
Price from£364.07per night
Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo, MI, an IHG Hotel, hotel in New Buffalo

Featuring free WiFi and an indoor pool, this 2-star Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo, MI offers accommodation in New Buffalo.

Your staff was stellar.
8.2
Scored 8.2
Very good
Rated very good
239 reviews
Price from£84.02per night
The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo, hotel in New Buffalo

Set in New Buffalo, 700 metres from New Buffalo Beach, The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo offers accommodation with a garden, free private parking, a shared lounge and a terrace.

We checked in online. It was convenient. However, it would’ve been nice to see a manager/owner other than guests sneaking in/out. A nice surprise was to come back at the end of the day to homemade muffins. They were delicious. The location was within walking distance to everything. Would recommend to stay here.
8.8
Scored 8.8
Fabulous
Rated fabulous
8 reviews
Price from£373.89per night
Quality Inn Near Interstate I94, hotel in New Buffalo

The newly built Quality Inn Near Interstate I94 is close to many area attractions.

It was quiet.
7.8
Scored 7.8
Good
Rated good
533 reviews
Price from£65.47per night
Fairfield Inn and Suites New Buffalo, hotel in New Buffalo

Featuring an indoor pool and hot tub, this New Buffalo, Michigan hotel is located along Interstate 94 and is 7 minutes’ drive from Four Winds Casino. Each room includes free Wi-Fi.

Breakfast was great! Close to the downtown.
7.8
Scored 7.8
Good
Rated good
202 reviews
Price from£109.86per night
Baymont by Wyndham New Buffalo, hotel in New Buffalo

Featuring a heated indoor pool and a free hot breakfast, the Baymont Inn – New Buffalo offers free WiFi access. The Four Winds Casino is 5 minutes’ drive from the hotel.

The location of the hotel was nice.
5.5
Scored 5.5
Average
Rated passable
311 reviews
Price from£49.26per night
Walking Distance To Beach And Shops, hotel in New Buffalo

Set just 2.1 km from New Buffalo Beach, Walking Distance To Beach And Shops provides accommodation in New Buffalo with access to a garden, barbecue facilities, as well as private check-in and...

8.4
Scored 8.4
Very good
Rated very good
37 reviews
Price from£232.62per night
4411 Inn & Suites, hotel in New Buffalo

4411 Inn & Suites offers accommodation in Michigan City. This 3-star hotel offers a concierge service. The hotel also features free WiFi and free private parking.

Loved it! Mike and Leaf were amazing and even offered up local places for dinner. The room was spotless and very nicely decorated, the outdoor area was very nice and inviting as well. We will definitely be back, I want this place to flourish.
9.2
Scored 9.2
Superb
Rated superb
87 reviews
Price from£111.78per night
Garden Grove Inn Bed and Breakfast, hotel in New Buffalo

Situated between Interstate 94 and Red Arrow Highway, this Union Pier bed and breakfast is located on a secluded acre of property full of tall trees and colorful gardens.

9.6
Scored 9.6
Exceptional
Rated exceptional
35 reviews
Price from£202.91per night
The Inn at Union Pier, hotel in New Buffalo

Less than 3 minutes’ walk from the sandy shores of Lake Michigan, this Union Pier bed and breakfast offers uniquely furnished rooms with free Wi-Fi. Guests can relax in the hot tub or sauna on site.

Great breakfast, very nice location with beach access. Staff was very friendly and helpful.
9.1
Scored 9.1
Superb
Rated superb
82 reviews
Price from£203.76per night
See all hotels in and around New Buffalo

Most booked hotels in New Buffalo in the past month

FAQs about hotels in New Buffalo


Subscribe to receive premium deals

Prices drop the moment you sign up!

What guests said about New Buffalo:

  • 10
    Scored 10

    Very nice, very clean and close enough to go to for an...

    Very nice, very clean and close enough to go to for an overnight stay and still be able to relax. Great restaurants and bars are all within minutes of each other. We love going to and staying in New Buffalo.
    Paul
    United States
  • 2.0
    Scored 2.0

    This was the most disgusting place I have ever seen.

    This was the most disgusting place I have ever seen. It run down to the ground. Bathrooms were out of order. No internet. No working locks on the room doors. People were smoking cigarettes in the rooms. Which is against state law. You should think again about listing them on your site. Now I'm not sure if I should use Booking.com again or not.
    Kathleen
    United States
  • 8.0
    Scored 8.0

    I think they could have breadfeast longer about a hour and...

    I think they could have breadfeast longer about a hour and they seem to not have enough food all the time. and you had to wait or did not have enough food . The food was good but they should have done better way of having food ready. The room was good but there was things left there in the night stand that seem like they did not clean. It was quite inside all night. It was close to things and easy to get to aroun New Buffalo It was clean in the hotel and most friendly to guest
    Dave
    United States
  • 8.0
    Scored 8.0

    New Buffalo is a cute town with the beach so close.

    New Buffalo is a cute town with the beach so close. Quite a few stores and restaurants are closed, probably due to COVID??? The ones that were open, had limited staff so seating and service was slow, but as long as you know the reason, just sit and enjoy the atmosphere. We ended up going to St. Joseph the next day, and truly enjoyed that town!!! Also Round Barn Winery and Tabor Hill Winery, in Baroda is a MUST!
    Sue Ann
    United States
  • 10
    Scored 10

    We’ve stopped twice in New Buffalo on our way from New York...

    We’ve stopped twice in New Buffalo on our way from New York to Milwaukee. We love Redamaks and the sunset. Both trips I’ve gotten a haircut at George’s Hair Styling. He’s a jewel in New Buffalo. Lot of nice shops and restaurants.
    Kevin
  • 8.0
    Scored 8.0

    Very small town..

    Very small town.. One main strip with a handful of shops and restaurants. Dining out got expensive -$60-$100 for 4.. No big box stores or smaller restaurants. We enjoyed our time during this pandemic and appreciated the small town feel. It wasn't too busy except at the beach..we were still able to spread out. We will go back!
    Nikki
    United States

Explore guest reviews of hotels in New Buffalo

  • 4.9
    Scored 4.9
    Disappointing
    Rated disappointing
     · 257 reviews
    Place was a nightmare, absolutely the worst place you could imagine, I wish I could put my pictures I took of the trash, it truly looked abandoned, I instantly was on defense with the location and area. Was very worried for my family, I instantly locked the doors and left the area. I am truly upset that booking.com would allow this. Absolutely don’t let your family stay here. There is a 35 dollar a night motel right down the road that I would trust way more then this. I lost my money it was worth the loss.
    S
    Scott
    United States
  • 9.5
    Scored 9.5
    Exceptional
    Rated exceptional
     · 2 reviews
    We had a great time at Stone's Throw Cottage. The location was great; a short, scenic walk to the harbor, beach, restaurants, ice cream shops and more. The neighborhood was quiet and easy to walk around. The house itself was very cozy, clean and well equipped. The kitchen was filled with essentials, there were plenty of pillows, blankets, towels, etc. The additional sunroom area turned out to be our favorite place in the house to eat, relax and hang out.
    Katarzyna
    United States
  • From £66.17 per night
    7.8
    Scored 7.8
    Good
    Rated good
     · 533 reviews
    We were expecting a more relaxed motel, and our expectations were exceeded by how the place was clean, comfortable, and offering amenities that are at more expensive hotels (toiletries, microwave, tv, fridge, continental breakfast). I liked the big mirror in the room and spacious bathroom.
    Rachel
    United States
  • From £131.48 per night
    7.8
    Scored 7.8
    Good
    Rated good
     · 202 reviews
    Breakfast was typical hotel breakfast! There was hot sausage and fresh eggs. The room was nicer than I thought it would be based off of the pictures. The staff was friendly and checkin and checkout was simple and quick.
    Brittany
    United States
  • 8.9
    Scored 8.9
    Fabulous
    Rated fabulous
     · 140 reviews
    It was very convenient to the beach and traveling to different sites in the area. The room was very large. Having the kitchen meant we could do breakfast before leaving and bring back leftovers. Felt very beachy.
    Jennifer
    United States
  • 4.9
    Scored 4.9
    Disappointing
    Rated disappointing
     · 257 reviews
    There was nothing to like. Did not even stay the night. Left immediately after seeing room and premises and found a different hotel and called directly. Did not use booking.com
    Sandra
    United States
  • 4.9
    Scored 4.9
    Disappointing
    Rated disappointing
     · 257 reviews
    The only good thing was about this stay was it was close to the beach and New buffalo to shop, eat and walk around. The bed was clean. Nice to have a refrigerator and microwave.
    T
    Trey
    United States
  • 9.5
    Scored 9.5
    Exceptional
    Rated exceptional
     · 2 reviews
    Great location, convenient to the New Buffalo town center as well as an easy golf cart ride to the beach. Nice relaxing location, with its own pool which our kids loved.
    Guy
    United States
  • 8.4
    Scored 8.4
    Very good
    Rated very good
     · 37 reviews
    Pretty, open layout with natural light in living area. Comfortable beds. Efficient heating and cooling of whole house. Overall clean and organized home.
    Suzanne
    United States
  • From £131.48 per night
    7.8
    Scored 7.8
    Good
    Rated good
     · 202 reviews
    The staff was excellent! Our room was very clean and spacious! Great location for visiting friends in nearby New Buffalo and Three Oaks!
    Thomas
    United States
  • 8.9
    Scored 8.9
    Fabulous
    Rated fabulous
     · 140 reviews
    Perfect walking location to beach and bars and restaurants. Charming rooms with private decks. Simply put, beats a hotel any time.
    J
    JAMES
    United States
  • From £91.66 per night
    8.2
    Scored 8.2
    Very good
    Rated very good
     · 239 reviews
    Great hotel, nice, well situated with a nice pool. The staff was super nice and the property is clean. Will stay again.
    Virginie
    United States
  • From £66.17 per night
    7.8
    Scored 7.8
    Good
    Rated good
     · 533 reviews
    It was spacious, the coffee and breakfast was good. Every place we went to was in the vicinity of the hotel
    Tyshonna
    United States
  • From £55.14 per night
    5.5
    Scored 5.5
    Average
    Rated passable
     · 311 reviews
    Location was very close to the beach and restaurants! Pool area at hotel was pretty basic but enjoyable!!
    J
    Jamie
    United States
  • 4.9
    Scored 4.9
    Disappointing
    Rated disappointing
     · 257 reviews
    The room has everything new, it's nice to see a hotel rehab. I like the colors of walls and the floor.
    Angelica
    United States
  • 9.1
    Scored 9.1
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 17 reviews
    We had a great time at this hotel - very clean, welcoming and well appointed! Would 100% stay again!
    Hannah
    United Kingdom
  • 9.3
    Scored 9.3
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 4 reviews
    Excellent location to downtown new Buffalo. A cozy cottage with a wonderful fire pit.
    Brigid Presecky
    United States
  • From £91.66 per night
    8.2
    Scored 8.2
    Very good
    Rated very good
     · 239 reviews
    Hotel clean, comfortable and felt safe and conveniently off the highway.
    Victoria
    United States
  • 4.9
    Scored 4.9
    Disappointing
    Rated disappointing
     · 257 reviews
    It was cheaper than the other hotels close by and air con worked well.
    A
    Anonymous
    United Kingdom
  • From £55.14 per night
    5.5
    Scored 5.5
    Average
    Rated passable
     · 311 reviews
    The location of the hotel was nice.
    L
    Lewis
    United States
gogless