Staff were wonderful, rooms were well designed, fun little pool and nice breakfast

Stayed in September 2024

Sound outside carries into the room

Retro but modern rooms

Stayed in September 2024

The key cards were a pain. We had to have them reprogrammed just about every time. After the first time, and advice from the staff, we kept them in separate areas away from phones, and STILL every time we had to come down to have them re done.

Convenient location, great staff and clean.

Stayed in September 2024

A little more than I usually pay for staying at a hotel for one night.

Nice location in a cozy setting nice restaurant and pool area

Stayed in July 2024

Location is nice but a bit far of from locations where activities are. In San Diego you drive anyway.

Amazing Breakfast, warm pool, nice interior in the room, parking in front of the door.

Stayed in June 2024

bed frame was really noisy. creaked everytime you turn over. but mattress and pillows are super comfy

the vibe is awesome. very cool retro motel. awesome bar. food choices are limited but the food was outstanding

Stayed in May 2024

The noise isolation is not good enough. I could hear sounds from neighbouring rooms obviously. The bed is too soft for me. Limited parking slots, but it was not difficult to park in nearby streets.

It is clean and well-organised. The staff are nice. Good location.

Stayed in March 2024

water pressure in shower very low, even for California, bed too low to floor, road in front of hotel seemed dangerous to cross on foot or bicycle (which I did not rent) due to speeding cars. A stop sign given location of hotel in relation to harbor, would be sensible. No apparent assistance for carrying luggage up stairs

lovely, room and furnishing, good soundproofing, comfortable mattress helpful receptionist, good, included breakfast with nice fruit, beautiful, outdoor pool and restaurant

Stayed in February 2024

Slightly more facilities (mini fridge in the room, breakfast in the restaurant) would have been nice, but we managed very well without

The room was very nice and the staff were extremely helpful and friendly. The hotel was also easy to reach and in walking distance of the sea.

Stayed in January 2024

The only thing we didn't like was the fact there were no outlets near the bed. We had to charge our phones over by the desk.

Very comfortable beds & pillows

Stayed in November 2023

Weak wifi, loud events, and a strange smell in the room

Great bed, towels, amenities, decor.

Stayed in October 2023

Sadly the restaurant is closed on Sunday and Monday nights (the 2 nights I stayed) so there was not much going on in the hotel whilst I was there - it was very quiet. I was told that it’s a great place for cocktails (when open!). It would also have been great to have some comfortable loungers by the pool rather than just upright chairs.

The location was great with good coffee shops and eateries and Shelter Island all within walking distance. The room was very clean and airy. The bed was so comfortable and the toiletries provided were great too. The hotel is small and welcoming and the staff were friendly and helpful.

Stayed in September 2023

The AC didn’t work. The place was slowly dealing with the aftermath of the hurricane, so the pool seemed to need upkeep.

The rooms and restaurant are stylish and comfortable.

Stayed in August 2023

Wi-Fi not working in the room.

Super comfortable bedroom!

Stayed in June 2023

Lack of iron and ironing board and coffee maker in the rooms was disappointing. I wouldn’t usually miss an iron but travelling for work sometimes requires it. I’d recommend coffee makers in the rooms.

Great property, beautifully renovated and nice style with lots of lively details. Comfortable spaces.

Stayed in March 2023

The pricing structure could be more straightforward; the Pearl charges a $20 convenience fee for what other hotels would build into the price, e.g. wifi, coffee.

Elevated but not luxurious decor. Location is great, you can walk directly to the water and nearby shops.

Stayed in March 2023

close to a busy room, no parking available and not breakfast in the room price

room decoration, it was clean

Stayed in January 2023

some aspects of the hotel are looking a little tired. all the extra fees add up and really increase the overall nightly charge. the resort fee is a bit silly, given the winter time pool (shaded and not really heated enough to go in) situation.

Third time at the pearl. we like the aesthetic over typical hotels. the restaurant is convenient and has good quality snacks and local beer on tap. bar/restaurant staff are great.

Stayed in December 2022

I think that price wise, it can be slightly less.

I loved the vibe that the boutique hotel created compared to how other hotels in the area looked. I also think the staff regardless of their role, made me feel wonderful as a guest. I had a front desk employee clean the pool when I went down there to swim.

Stayed in August 2022

Parking is an issue.

We liked the vibe of the hotel. Great staff! Excellent restaurant and fun bar. We enjoyed movie night by the pool.

Stayed in August 2022

The room we had didn't have a plug for the CPAP machine i use at night. They did compensate us with knocking off the parking fee.

The day we arrived, happy hour was all day! They had special pricing and good snacking food.

Stayed in July 2022

Our shower was broken, water did not drain. No mini fridge in room. No self-service ice, no room service. Very loud

Unique ambiance, good food & cocktails, excellent customer service. Small and cozy. Nice pool, not too crowded.

Stayed in July 2022

It was loud in our room.

Stayed in June 2022

The restaurant was closed.

Overall, the hotel is very good. The bar was open with a lovely happy hour, the pool was nice, other guests respected the quiet hours and our room had a window with a view of the screen where they projected movies. It's walking distance to restaurants, coffee shops and deli for small items.

Stayed in April 2022