The heat in the room. The sink tap. The heat in the hotel toilets

The location was excellent, our room was lovely and the outdoor seating area was excellent. The receptionist was very pleasant and welcoming

Stayed in July 2024

The only issue was that the parking was a 15 min walk away, which when laden with bags and a friend who has to use a walking stick, this was a chore but we got tghrough it. It was worth it in the end.

The room was very comfortable and accessible. It had lots of nice touches and decent toilettries, towls and linen. it was a very quiet room and peaceful night. I especially liked the cooked breakfast. much better than most I would say. Staff really poite, helpful and friendly.

Stayed in July 2024

Wasn’t clear that the room booked wasn’t in the property itself but almost like a little annexe of chalet type rooms to the rear.

Great character building, nice bar / restaurant abd excellent breakfast.

Stayed in July 2024

Room was a bit hot

We got an upgrade and the breakfast plus old furnishings

Stayed in July 2024

Nothing!

Just an amazing place to stay, excellent location, lovely room, friendly staff and an awesome breakfast.

Stayed in July 2024

Nothing to complain about

Everything was perfect, comfy beds, quiet room, fan to cool down the room, choice of hot drinks, bathrobes, fridge, water and glasses, everything we needed. Breakfast was exceptional. Will definitely recommend this hotel to friends and will return

Stayed in June 2024

Can be noisy due to beer garden, delivery vans and dustbin collections, but would stay here again.

Fantastic location, hotel lovely good staff.

Stayed in June 2024

Great hotel in a great location. It's super central to where we need to be, and the breakfast selection is very nice.

Stayed in June 2024

Nothing

Everything was exceptional 👌 👏

Stayed in June 2024

Bit noisy in early evening, but quiet by 11pm

Good choice for breakfast , too big if anything. Very good.

Stayed in June 2024

Location is Great . Room clean and convenient

Stayed in June 2024

Central location and open air bar area. Room was small but cosy with everything we might need including fresh milk ( not horrible UHT capsules!) Lovely cooked breakfast options.

Stayed in June 2024

Nothing

Beautiful building, rooms were spotlessly clean and decorated excellently throughout

Stayed in June 2024

Ideal city centre location. Very relaxing.

Stayed in June 2024

N/A

Excellent room and comfy bed

Stayed in June 2024

The evening meal we had was lovely but there were only 6 chips ,which as tasty as they were, was a little disappointing.

The room I booked was very accessible for myself and my disabled daughter. The staff were very welcoming and helpful . A lovely little boutique hotel in a very good location.

Stayed in June 2024

Loved everything about this Hotel

Very Modern and Beautifully Designed

Stayed in June 2024

loved it

Stayed in June 2024

Lovely staff. Fabulous location. Beautiful rooms and lovely breakfast (although for those with decreasing eye sight the print on the breakfast could be bigger 😂). Ive stayed in a number of well known, more expensive hotels in York and I thought Judges outclassed them all. I will definitely be back.

Stayed in June 2024

Nothing everything was perfect

Friendly staff ,room was beautiful and so comfortable, fantastic location

Stayed in May 2024

We had no complaints.

We were given a complimentary upgrade to the two best rooms in the hotel, the two original judges' lodging rooms. Quite stunning rooms.

Stayed in June 2024

Our room was in the courtyard right outside the pub, so the blinds had to stay closed unless we wanted the table outside to see in. When we checked in I thought it was going to be a problem with the noise at bedtime, but it actually wasn't, they must have stopped seating people there in the evening. It wasn't a concern for us at all, just something to be mindful of.

Newly renovated room, perfect location in York. Very clean and comfortable. The restaurant/pub was very popular so reservations need to be made in advance.

Stayed in May 2024

Location perfect room perfect food delicious staff super

Stayed in June 2024

Only one thing: breakfast on each of the days felt very rushed as though they couldn’t wait for us to go. The area in the cellar bar is rather cramped - (no objections to that) but two people need a table for four as there is nowhere to put the multiple plates etc.-so very efficient that my cooked breakfast arrived while I was still eating a bowl of fruit which I lifted up and could not then put down. The waitress whose first language was not English asked me what I wanted her to do about it, ‘my dear?’ She certainly did not mean any offence, so it was quite funny. Evening meals were never like that - staff were very good, as is the food. It sounds simplistic, but small breakfast plates could help?

Location is superb - very friendly and accessible for elderly ladies. We chose the right rooms as we had stayed there before, The management staff are very good indeed.

Stayed in June 2024